Top Concrete Service

Topical Vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers: Which Works Better?

Topical vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers

Concrete is a versatile material. You can find it in driveways, patios, and floors. However, it needs protection to last longer. Concrete sealers shield the surface from stains, moisture, and wear. But, the question arises: Which type of sealer works better, penetrating concrete sealers vs. topical? This blog will dive deep into both to help you make an informed choice. Let’s explore these sealers, their benefits, and their drawbacks.


What Are Topical Concrete Sealers?


Topical sealers sit on the surface of the concrete. They form a protective film that shields against moisture, stains, and chemicals. Additionally, they enhance the concrete’s appearance, giving it a glossy or matte finish.


Benefits of Topical Concrete Sealers:

  • Enhanced Appearance: Topical sealers provide a shiny or matte finish. With this, it enhances the aesthetic appeal.
  • Stain Protection: They block stains from oil, grease, and other substances.
  • Easy Application: You can apply topical sealers with a roller or sprayer. With this, it makes them user-friendly.

Drawbacks of Topical Concrete Sealers:

  • Maintenance: Topical sealers require reapplication every 1-3 years.
  • Surface Wear: They can wear off quickly in high-traffic areas.
  • Slipperiness: Some topical sealers can make the surface slippery when wet.

What Are Penetrating Concrete Sealers?


Penetrating sealers soak into the concrete. They react with the concrete to form a barrier that repels water and contaminants. Moreover, these sealers are ideal for areas where slip resistance is crucial.


Benefits of Penetrating Concrete Sealers:


  • Long-Lasting Protection: Penetrating sealers provide long-lasting protection, often for up to 10 years.
  • Natural Look: They do not change the appearance of the concrete.
  • Slip Resistance: Penetrating sealers maintain the natural texture, reducing slip risks.

Drawbacks of Penetrating Concrete Sealers:


  • Limited Aesthetic Enhancement: They do not enhance the concrete’s appearance.
  • Stain Resistance: They offer less protection against surface stains compared to topical sealers.
  • Cost: Penetrating sealers can be more expensive upfront.

Topical vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers: Which to Choose?


Choosing between topical and penetrating concrete sealers depends on your needs. So, let’s compare these two types in different scenarios.


For Driveways:


Driveways face heavy traffic and oil stains. Therefore, a penetrating sealer might be the best choice. Moreover, it offers long-lasting protection without changing the surface’s appearance.


For Patios:


Patios benefit from a combination of aesthetics and protection. With this, a topical sealer can enhance the patio’s look while providing protection against stains and moisture.


For Indoor Floors:


Indoor floors need protection and aesthetic enhancement. With this, topical sealers work well here. Moreover, they add a glossy finish and protect against spills.


Topical Vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers: Performance Comparison


Here’s a quick performance comparison between topical vs. penetrating concrete sealers:

Criteria Topical Sealers Penetrating Sealers
1-3 years
Up to 10 years
Glossy or matte finish
Natural look
Slip Resistance
Can be slippery when wet
Maintains natural texture
Stain Protection
Requires careful application

Topical Vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers: Cost Comparison


Here’s a cost analysis table to understand the financial aspect better:

Type of Sealer Initial Cost Reapplication Cost (over 10 years) Total Cost (over 10 years)
Topical Sealer
$0.20/sq ft
$0.15/sq ft per reapplication
$0.50/sq ft
Penetrating Sealer
$0.50/sq ft
$0.50/sq ft

As seen in the table, the total cost over 10 years is almost the same. However, the initial investment for penetrating sealers is higher.


Practical Tips for Application


Topical Sealers:


  1. Clean the Surface: Ensure the concrete is clean and dry.
  2. Apply Evenly: Use a roller or sprayer for even application.
  3. Allow Drying Time: Let the sealer dry completely before use.

Penetrating Sealers:


  1. Clean Thoroughly: Remove all dirt, oil, and stains.
  2. Apply Generously: Apply enough sealer to soak into the concrete.
  3. Dry Completely: Allow the sealer to dry fully before use.


Topical Vs. Penetrating Concrete Sealers: Other Considerations




Moreover, environmental factors play a crucial role in choosing between topical vs. penetrating concrete sealers. Topical sealers can sometimes contain higher levels of VOCs (volatile organic compounds), which may not be eco-friendly. Penetrating sealers, on the other hand, usually have lower VOC levels. Therefore, you prioritize environmental safety, penetrating sealers might be the better option. However, here is a list of suppliers that are VOC Compliant that may come hand for you. 


Weather Resistance


Furthermore, the weather conditions in your area can influence your choice. Topical sealers can become brittle and peel in extreme weather conditions, such as very hot or very cold temperatures. However, penetrating sealers adapt better to various weather conditions since they work below the surface. Consequently, for areas with extreme weather variations, penetrating sealers provide more reliable protection.


Long-Term Maintenance


Additionally, consider the long-term maintenance requirements. Topical sealers need more frequent reapplication, typically every 1-3 years. This can be time-consuming and costly over the long run. On the other hand, penetrating sealers require less maintenance, lasting up to 10 years. Therefore, if you prefer a low-maintenance option, penetrating sealers are a more practical choice.

When to Call a Professional


Moreover, you might wonder if you should apply the sealer yourself or hire a professional. Applying topical sealers can be a DIY project, especially if you have experience with home improvement tasks. However, for penetrating sealers, professional application is often recommended. Take note, professionals ensure thorough surface preparation and correct application, guaranteeing optimal results.


Your Next Steps


In conclusion, choosing between topical vs. penetrating concrete sealers depends on your specific needs. If you want long-lasting protection without altering the concrete’s look, go for penetrating sealers. On the other hand, if you need enhanced appearance and stain protection, topical sealers are the way to go.

For the best results and professional advice, contact Cesars Concrete. We offer expert guidance and top-quality service to ensure your concrete surfaces remain protected and looking great.

Remember, the right sealer can extend the life of your concrete and keep it looking its best. So, choose wisely and enjoy the benefits of well-protected concrete.

Feel free to reach out to Cesars Concrete for any questions or to get started on your concrete sealing project today!

Call us at: (970) 420-9040

Share This:



Just fill in your basic info and we'll do the rest.